Showing posts with label Tiger Farm. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tiger Farm. Show all posts

Saturday, July 12, 2014

China Admits to Tiger Skin Trade but not to Bones





China Admits to Tiger Skin Trade but not to Bones

So China has come out and admitted that :

 'we don't ban trade in tiger skins but we do ban trade in tiger bones,'

So does this make it any less bad? Most definitely not. The bones remain in the 'zoo' in which the tiger has been skinned. These will have been put into vats of rice wine and steeped for a few months to produce Tiger Bone Wine........




.......which, as far as I am aware there is no ban on trade. I daresay that the bones are rendered down afterwards to produce Tiger Bone Glue and other pseudo Medicinal Ointments.



So what has changed? Nothing! Again I am assuming that is still against the law in China to kill these tigers for the trade and so they are starved to death to keep this horrific trade going.

China 'admits' trading in tiger skins

11 July 2014

Learn More








And lets not forget the Rhinoceros



Thursday, April 1, 2010

If Tiger Farms Were To Close

If Tiger Farms Were To Close




There are around 6000 Tigers held in captivity in China today. It is estimated that around 5000 of these are held in what are termed ‘Tiger Farms’. This number may well be an underestimate.


These Chinese Tigers are often referred to as ‘rare’ Siberian or Amur Tigers by the press. In essence this is true because the Siberian Tiger Panthera tigris altaica is rare, rare in the wild. There may only be as few as 30 wild animals remaining in China. The other Chinese Tiger sub-species is the South China Tiger Panthera tigris amoyensis which may already be extinct outside of zoos.

The Tiger Farm Tigers are not rare because they are no longer of the Siberian or South Chinese sub-species. They are generic Tigers. Hybrids. Generic Tigers are animals which have been cross bred across sub-species and where sub-species have been bred brother to sister, mother to son over generations. Such animals are virtually useless from the point of view of conservation. Once a Tiger has been hybridised then it and all its progeny, forever will be hybrids.


ISIS (International Species Information System) has three studbooks for the Amur Tiger. One for the species, one for the group and one for hybrids. Whereas these list a total of some 500 animals worldwide, not a single specimen is listed for China. Note though that 500 is really a drop in the ocean because this is only a listing of the responsible holders who actively participate in official breeding management programmes. Any zoo which holds Siberian/Amur tigers and claims to be involved in conservation and is not ISIS listed is not telling the truth.

The US Fish and Wildlife Service sensibly stated:

Generic or crossed tigers cannot be used for enhancement of propagation of the species, however they can be used in a manner that should enhance survival of the species in the wild. Examples include exhibition in a manner designed to educate the public about the ecological role and conservation needs of the species and satisfaction of demand for tigers so that wild specimens or captive purebred subspecies are not used.”



The only problem with this approach is that the holders of these generic tigers continue to breed them. There is a real and genuine need for more spaces in captivity to hold known specimens of the various sub-species. Perhaps not breeding animals, but there just in case they are needed. A‘not keeping all your eggs in one basket’ approach. Taking up the room in captivity with generic tigers is harming the chances of managed populations of Tigers surviving.

Furthermore the IUCN Guidelines for Re-introductions states:

It is desirable that source animals come from wild populations. If there is a choice of wild populations to supply founder stock for translocation, the source population should ideally be closely related genetically to the original native stock and show similar ecological characteristics (morphology, physiology, behaviour, habitat preference) to the original sub-population.”

And

If captive or artificially propagated stock is to be used, it must be from a population which has been soundly managed both demographically and genetically, according to the principles of contemporary conservation biology.”

And furthermore

The World Zoo Conservation Strategy says:


Demographic stability is needed to ensure that an adequate number of animals of breeding age are available to reproduce at the rates needed to increase or maintain the population at its desired size. Healthy populations are needed to ensure that animals are capable of breeding when needed. Genetic diversity is required for populations to remain healthy and adapt to changing environments (i.e. experience natural selection). Ex situ breeding programmes need to preserve this diversity, otherwise the long-term fitness of these populations will be compromised.”

To which they add

A primary goal of cooperative ex situ breeding programmes for threatened and endangered species is to support in situ conservation. This may be through rescue of species imminently threatened with extinction in the wild, through research, education, or promotion efforts that support in situ populations, or simply as genetic and demographic reservoirs serving as backups for endangered wild populations.”

This would clearly not be the case with any of the Chinese Tiger Farm animals.

It also applies to White Tigers, which are also very common in Chinese Zoos and often promoted as something different and special. White Tigers only exist in captivity because of continual deliberate and harmful inbreeding. Today there is probably not a single captive White Tiger anywhere in the world that could be considered as genetically important. Undeniably beautiful the breeding has resulted in numerous genetic defects which are not immediately obvious. Evidence enough though to stop breeding and maintenance for purely commercial gain.



Generic Tigers are a major problem wherever they are located be it the US, Australasia, Europe or China. Generic Tigers are unregulated. Breeding and disposal are at the whim of the holder. In some locations a reporting structure may be present and in others not. This leaves the Tigers open to abuse. No-one knows how many are born, how many died. No-one knows either what happened to the bodies after death. It is barely a hop and skip to disappearing into the black market of illegal animal products.


If the Tiger Farms of China were told to cease operation there would be a major problem. There is no question about releasing them into the wild. The population in the wild is already in trouble. Adding more tigers to it would only increase the problems for the Tigers that are already there.

So where could these 5 or 6 thousand tigers go? A small number, perhaps a hundred or so which could be shown to be pure and with a proven lineage may perhaps be taken into the official breeding programme, but the rest?

It is unlikely that a few thousand newspaper readers are going to dip their hands in their pockets to rescue 6,000 tigers as was done recently for a dozen Lions from Romania. Although most people are wholly against Tiger farming, and rightfully so, there would be a huge howl of protest at the suggestion that these Tigers should be euthanized.

The idea that all breeding should cease in the Tiger Farms and that the animals should live out their natural lives sounds reasonable but just who is going to foot the bill? Even if each one were to live just ten years it is a long time to maintain something which is to all intents and purposes, useless. Maintaining five thousand is just not a serious option. So what happens next?

First published on Newsvine

Thursday, March 25, 2010

Tiger Horror Story - Watch This Video

Al Jazeera has done it again. Watch this excellent but horrifying report from China.


Be Warned...this is disturbing.

Sunday, February 21, 2010

Tiger Farming Exposed

The story below makes quite distressing reading and the photographs make interesting and disturbing viewing. Read and forward on. Of course they don't call these places 'Tiger Farms' they say Zoo and Wildlife Park in the same way that in Thailand the Tiger Temple and Sri Racha Tiger Zoo give themselves other names too. Sadly some of the so called good zoos in the West are encouraging such activities by letting their visitors pose with tigers. Such photographic sessions give the green light to the bad zoos who then breed tigers specifically for the purpose. Every year there are more cubs. Tigers disappear out of the back door. Good zoos should stop the posing today....and let people know why. - Peter

                                                 Shame On You

Exposed: Dark secret of the farm where tigers' bodies are plundered to make £185 wine

Behind rusted bars, a skeletal male tiger lies panting on the filthy concrete floor of his cage, covered in sores and untreated wounds. His once-fearsome body is so emaciated it is little more than a pitiful pile of fur and bones.


Death is surely a matter of days away and can only come as a welcome release. Wardens at the wildlife park in southwest China say, indifferently, that they do not expect him to see the start of the Year of the Tiger which began last Sunday.

'What can we do?' a female park official asks a small huddle of visitors with a sigh and a casual shrug. 'He's dying, of course, but we have to keep feeding him until he does. It's against the law to kill tigers.'

Instead, it seems, they die slowly of neglect. In row after row of foul, cramped cages, more tigers lie alone, crippled and dying. One is hunched up against the side of its cage with its neck grotesquely deformed. Another, blinded in one eye, lies motionless.


This shabby, rundown park in Guilin - one of China's main tourist cities - is home to the world's biggest single collection of tigers. Yet it is never included on foreigners' tour itineraries.

For here, 1,500 captive tigers - around half as many as there are thought to be remaining in the wild - live out miserable lives in squalid conditions.

Each tiger costs around £6 a day to feed, and it is easy to see that the small clusters of visitors paying £7.50 each to wander around the cages and watch bizarre animal shows cannot possibly cover even the cost of food for the vast park.

The reason is the tigers, mostly Siberian, are far more valuable dead than alive.

For a 55lb pile of bones from a single tiger can be worth up to £225,000. There is a hugely lucrative trade in the skeletons at the Guilin park.

Dead tigers are driven 200 miles from the park, officially called the Xiongshen Tiger and Bear Mountain Village, to a huge subterranean complex where their fur is stripped from their carcasses and their bones collected to make tiger wine that can sell for £185 a bottle.

So for the park, where the tigers are bred for their bones, every year is the Year of the Tiger, and conservationists fear that the vile trade could be helping push some species of wild big cat into extinction.

On paper, China has signed international wildlife treaties that ban all trade in tiger body parts and claims to have outlawed the industry.

In reality, Xiongshen and other parks like it operate in a grey area of the law, using the bones of animals that have died naturally in captivity to produce 'medicinal' wine, apparently with the government's blessing.

Tigers have been used in Chinese traditional medicine for centuries. Their eyeballs are used to treat epilepsy, their bile to stop convulsions, their whiskers to sooth toothache and their penises as a potent sexual tonic.

The most valuable parts, however, are the bones, which are used to make wine that is said to cure rheumatism and arthritis, and prolong life.

Despite its rapid modernisation, the use of traditional medicine in China has increased rather than declined because more people can afford exotic treatments.

Tiger bone wine, made by steeping tiger bones in huge vats of potent 38 per cent-proof rice wine, has for more than 2,000 years been one of the most expensive and sought-after Chinese traditional medicines, believed to bestow the tiger's power and strength upon the taker.


It is popular among wealthy middle-aged men including, reportedly, some of the Communist Party's senior officials and is said to have been used by modern China's founder Chairman Mao Tse-Tung himself, in the superstitious belief that it counters the effects of ageing and boosts flagging sex drive.

Because of the scarcity of tigers, a single bottle of tiger bone wine from a rare vintage year can sell for £600 or more. As well as a supposed medical remedy, it is a prestigious drink sometimes shared between men at high-level political or business meetings, or drunk at lavish parties.

The lucrative trade has accelerated the disappearance of all but a handful of China ' s remaining wild tigers as peasants turn poachers to track down the animals, knowing just one will make them more money than a farmer can earn in a decade.

Millionaire Zhou Weisen, who is 47 and was born in the Year of the Tiger himself, realised at an early age he could make his fortune by keeping tigers in wretched captivity. He opened the Guilin park with 60 tigers in 1993, breeding them intensively so their numbers boomed to today's population of 1,500.

The park has the atmosphere of a medieval circus, with animals treated in a way that would cause outrage in any western country.

Twice a day, a few relatively tame tigers are put on leashes and led out to amuse small groups of visitors.

For the equivalent of £1.80 a time, parents and their children get the opportunity to feed strips of beef to a scrawny, undernourished young tiger in the care of a park keeper who, with no sense of irony, tells them the tiger is a 'symbol of power in the animal kingdom'.

Then a ramshackle carnival float decorated with pictures of tigers is led out with a collection of big cats cowering on its deck where they are forced by park keepers to stand up on their hind legs, and beaten with wooden stakes if they do not obey.

Parents clap and shriek with laughter while children look on with bemused grins as the daily ritual is performed.

A closer look reveals that one of the performing tigers has a tumour on his left leg the size of a football. Other tigers have untreated wounds and scars from thrashings or fights with other tigers.

Only a few hundred of the park's animals are on view to visitors. The majority are hidden from sight in row after row of cages outside the public area of the park. Here, bored tigers crammed four or more to a cage, pace restlessly back and forth.

Others are kept locked in small, concrete enclosures, spending their days in perpetual darkness. They occasionally jump up on their hind legs to peer through narrow, slit windows, to get a rare glimpse of daylight.

Welfare expert David Neale from Animals Asia, said after inspecting the park: 'These animals are kept in appalling conditions and it is clear that many are suffering from malnutrition. And if what the public can see is so appalling, can you imagine what the conditions are like for the tigers hidden from view?'


Ironically, the park is littered with billboards proclaiming the owners' desire to protect wildlife. At the end of their tour of the park, visitors are directed to a 'science hall' where a complete tiger skeleton is displayed in a Perspex case.

This building is decorated with pictures showing a cave lined with earthenware jars.

'Each jar contains 500kg of rice wine with a complete set of tiger bones,' saleswoman Miss Li tells us with a practised patter.

'The wine is brewed in mountain caves a few hundred kilometres away where the water is ideal. Top [Communist Party] officials like to drink this wine. We serve it to them whenever they visit.'

Cutting hurriedly to the chase before the next group of guests finish their tour of the park and enter the science hall, she then offers the tiger wine in three, six and nine-year vintages at £60, £92 and £185 a bottle.

Miss Li assures us that if we buy here, our tiger wine comes with a cast-iron guarantee of quality.

'We have more than 1,500 tigers,' she says. 'There is no lack of raw materials for us. There are a few hundred dead tigers lying in our freezers. I can promise you that we sell only authentic tiger products.

'You know, of course, that the tiger is a protected animal but the government does allow us to trade tigers that have died naturally, as a way of helping us financially.'

Asked whether they all died natural deaths, she replied vaguely: 'Many of them die from illness or in fights with other tigers.'

Park owner Mr Zhou is also the owner of the secretive, subterranean factory 200 miles from Guilin where the bones and tiger bodies are processed in vast cellars storing up to 8,000 tons of tiger bone wine. The factory sells around 200,000 bottles a year and keeps up to 600 tiger skeletons at a time in huge vats.

The underground caverns, where witnesses have reported seeing entire tigers in 5ft high vats, are strictly off limits to visitors. But an assistant in the factory shop was keen to tell us about the scale of the operation.

'Our peak time is now, just before the Chinese New Year,' she said. 'We have so many orders and we simply haven't got enough boxes to complete the packaging, or workers to process the orders.'

The factory has a huge network of salespeople across China, she said, and charges steep distribution fees for anyone who wants to enjoy a slice of the business in tiger wine.

Factory sales manager Miss Wang told our interpreter over the phone: 'If you want to be a distributor, the licence will cost you 150,000 yuan (£14,000) a year for a provincial capital-and 80,000 yuan (£7,500) for a smaller city. A provincial sole distributor licence costs five million yuan (£468,000) a year.'

The factory's products are showcased in a sales office in the nearby town of Pingnan, where a variety of bottles of tiger bone wine are on show for potential buyers. But even here, deep in the Chinese countryside, the trade in tigers is a secret guarded with paranoid intensity.

As I took pictures of the outside of the sales office, I was approached by two security guards who demanded to look at my camera and insisted I deleted any pictures of the building.


They held me for 20 minutes and made frantic phone calls before letting me go once they were satisfied my camera's memory was empty.



Hundreds of miles south in Shenzhen, on the border with Hong Kong, the city's licensed distributor - who gets his tiger bone wine from the Guilin park - runs his business from the ground floor shop of a private apartment complex.

Lu Xi Ning, who is in his early 40s, has known Zhou Weisen of the Guilin tiger farm for more than ten years.

Visitors to his wine shop are allowed in by appointment only. 'It's a sensitive business,' he tells me in a room containing bottles of tiger bone wine of different vintages.

'My business has been improving in the last three years. But I cannot advertise,' he says as he pours tea. 'It is reliant on regulars and recommendations. Customers come back again and again though. More people want our products because of the Year of the Tiger.'

Praising its health benefits, Lu said: 'I have been drinking it every day for the past three years. I recommend one or two Chinese teacups each day. It is good for your circulation.' He added with a knowing wink: 'It is particularly good for men.'

Taking us to one side, he said quietly: 'If you travel by plane, you'd better take the wine out of the tiger bottle and put it into a red wine bottle or a Pepsi bottle, just to be on the safe side. Then it should be fine.'

Jill Robinson, director of Animals Asia, has little doubt that the park has similar networks of sellers for other tiger parts, such as skins, teeth, eyeballs, whiskers and penises: all highly valued in Chinese traditional medicine.

Robinson, who visited the park last year, described it as being nothing more than a thinly disguised tiger farm.

'You can see that their remit is to keep the animals barely alive,' she said. 'They keep breeding and do not properly report births or deaths so they can use the bodies.'

It is a trade that Steve Broad, executive director of the international wildlife watchdog group TRAFFIC, described as 'a disaster' not only for China but the world's remaining wild tigers.

'It is inevitable that wild tiger products will get drawn into a market created by farmed tiger parts,' he said. 'These business people are creating a market that could be catastrophic for the wild tiger population.

'We are not talking about a medicine trade but a trade where the tiger tonic is seen as a pick-me-up and the people who use it are doing it for bravado. The rarer the animal the better. It is nurturing the worst possible market among the rich and naive.'

Another body fighting to halt the trade in tiger bones is the Environmental Investigation Agency (EIA). Spokeswoman Debbie Banks said: 'Tiger bone wine is not about tradition. It is about commerce. If China is truly committed, they will make a ban on all trade in tiger products happen. They need to stop farming and breeding tigers.

'The farmers are thinking of all possible loopholes to exploit. They even argue that because tiger bone is in the vat and not actually in the bottle, then it is legal to sell. They also argue that it is a tonic rather than a medicine and therefore not covered by the law.'

Appeals by the EIA to the Chinese government have so far fallen on deaf ears. 'The State Forestry Administration said it would cost millions to phase out the farms, and that we are interfering in sovereign issues,' Ms Banks said.


Traditional beliefs are, it seems, tough to shift. The Guilin park, whose owner boasts of how he has served tiger wine to some of China's top leaders, has been given a £700,000 government grant to build new cages for its 'scientific research'.

We saw some of those new cages being put to use during our visit, housing up to ten animals each as the park's breeding programme continues apace.

China's government has stubbornly resisted attempts to stop the illicit trade in tiger parts. Despite grudgingly introducing legislation banning the use of tiger bones in medicine, China argued at an international convention in 2007 that the ban on trading tiger parts had 'seriously impacted not only Chinese traditional culture but also the medicinal treatment and health care of the Chinese people'.

Tigers, the Chinese government argued to the astonishment of delegates from other countries, should be treated like crocodiles and farmed for their bones and skin.

Perhaps fittingly, China itself is likely to be one ........

Read Full Article and View Photographs

Monday, February 1, 2010

Tiger Farms



Tigers and other farmyard animals

For every one wild tiger alive in the world today, there may be three "farmed" tigers in China.




They have been bred for their hides but also their bones, which are used to infuse some wines prized in South East Asia.



Some in the region believe that the consumption of certain parts of a tiger's carcass can give strength and virility.



China banned the trade in tiger bones and products in 1993 but that has not stopped the practice, which is currently on the agenda of an international tiger conservation conference in Thailand.


According to the World Bank, which leads the Global Tiger Initiative (GTI), the trade is being spurred by privately run tiger farms in Asian countries. It has called for these farms to be shut down.




Tigers on the farms are kept in cages and are also allowed to chase cows or chickens for the amusement of the paying public.



"Our position is that tiger farms as an animal practice are cruel," said the World Bank's Keshav Varma, GTI's programme director, as he attended the conference in Hua Hin.



"They fan the potential use of tiger parts," he told the Associated Press news agency.



In order to get an idea of what goes on in these farms, which are often presented as parks for tourists, BBC World Service spoke to Judy Mills of Conservation International, who has visited some of them.



'Speed-breeding'



The world's entire surviving wild tiger population is somewhere between 3,600 and 3,200, conservationists believe.



In China, there are now close to 10,000 tigers on farms, says Ms Mills, while other estimates suggest the number may be around 5,000.



"These are speed-breeding factory farms," Conservation International's tiger specialist says.



According to her research, farm tigresses produce cubs at about three times or more their natural rate, bearing up to three litters a year. Cubs are often taken away from their mothers before they are properly weaned.



These cubs, she says, are usually made to suckle from other animals, such as pigs or dogs - their "wet nurse surrogates" - so that the tigresses can produce more young.



"The part [of the farm] which people rarely see is basically a winery in which the skeletons of grown tigers are cleaned and put into vats of wine," says Ms Mills.



The bones are steeped for years, she explains, and the length of the infusion determines the value of the wine.



Conservation International says it is very difficult to clarify the legal status of these farms in China.



"When I first visited a tiger farm in 1990, it was part of a fur farm raising racoon, dogs, mink and other fur-bearing animals for commercial use," says Ms Mills. "The owner of the farm was showing me the log of orders for tiger bones and skins and other parts and products from tigers.



"Then in 1993, because of international pressure, China banned its commercial trade in tiger bone and tiger bone products but, at the same time, these

For Full Story
 
Read more about Tiger Farming

Wednesday, January 27, 2010

China Scraps Plans To Legalise Trade in Tigers




China backs down from plan to legalise tiger trade


China has shelved plans to legalise trade in tiger parts and will instead increase its protection of wild tigers in a bid to save them from extinction.
 
The sale of bones, skins and other body parts was banned in China in 1993 in order to protect the country's declining tiger population. There are currently only between 18 and 24 wild tigers in China, down from over 4,000 in the 1950s.



However, officials from the State Forestry Administration (SFA) were on the verge of scrapping the ban last year, following pressure from China's tiger farms, who are keen to sell their stockpiles of farmed tiger parts.

 Practitioners of Chinese medicine have traditionally ground tiger bones into a health tonic, while the penis is used to increase virility and the whiskers are said to cure toothache.




Chinese tiger farmers argued that the ban should be lifted because it was having no discernible effect in increasing the wild tiger population. However, the SFA has now said it will maintain the ban and increase policing.



A new directive promises to link local forestry bureaus with other law enforcement officials to prevent poaching, and will order the destruction of any tiger part stockpiles

Read Full Story

Monday, January 4, 2010

Now China calls for Tiger Protection!

China wakes up, calls for protection of tigers

India’s newfound partnership with China on environment issues has yielded results in the area of tiger protection as well. In what could be seen as a new year’s gift for the Indian tiger, China’s State Forestry Administration has issued a directive calling for the protection of tigers, especially the need to step up action against illegal trade in tiger parts and products.


                                    Photo By: http://www.flickr.com/photos/30775272@N05/


Poaching and smuggling of tigers fuelled by China’s incessant demand for tiger parts has been a thorny issue between India and China. This vital conservation issue dominated Jairam Ramesh’s first visit to Beijing as minister of state for environment in August last year. At that time, however, the talks between India and China to save the endangered animal failed to make much progress. Now, it would seem that the Indian government’s efforts have made some impact.



The Chinese order is aimed at protecting tigers in the wild, enforcing laws against illegal trading of tiger parts & products and better management and monitoring of tiger farms. Though silence on the issue of closing down the tiger farms could continue to be a cause of concern for India’s effort at conserving tigers.



The order has called for improved protection of tigers and their prey in the wild. This will have to be done through efforts in “research, monitoring, anti-poaching and alleviating human-tiger conflict”. China has some 20-odd tigers in the wild.



It has also mandated a crackdown on illegal smuggling and trade of tiger parts and products. The order has specifically asked local forestry bureaus to collaborate with other law enforcement agencies to increase monitoring and undertake enforcement measures against tiger trade.



Officially, domestic trade in tiger parts is illegal in China. However, the ever-growing demand for tiger parts, which are used as aphrodisiacal drugs and to make Chinese traditional medicine, has contributed to a flourishing black market, which fuels increased poaching and smuggling of tigers out of India through the Nepal and Myanmar borders. The latest directive from the Chinese authorities seeks to address the issue by trying to curb this demand.



It calls for promoting public awareness to reduce consumption of tiger parts and a public rejection of illegal trade. It suggests encouraging and motivating the public to report wildlife crime to authorities. At the same time, those officials who repeatedly ignore public complaints about illegal trade will be held responsible.



The Chinese order has also called for increased monitoring and management of tiger captive breeding facilities. This will require creating a database that would track all tigers bred on these facilities, with special attention to tiger deaths in these farms. To prevent trade, stockpile of tiger bodies and parts should be sealed to prevent use.



Those facilities that do not have storage capabilities would be required to destroy stockpile, under the supervision of local authorities. Each tiger farm will be required to have permits and meet conditions before opening up for public viewing.



Nearly 4,000 tigers are bred in scores of these controversial tiger farms in China. While the government maintains that these farms have been developed to attract tourists, experts maintain that these farms are used to harvest tiger body parts, which are used in traditional Chinese medicine. Mr Ramesh has pushed for phasing out of tiger farms and destruction of stockpiles of tiger parts. The minister had sought an assurance from China’s minister
 
Full Article

Friday, November 6, 2009

No roaring success: Binh Duong’s lax tiger pens

If I can refer you back to my September 11th posting when I posed a number of, up to now, unanswered questions about the keeper killed in Dai Nam Zoo
'Keeper Killed by Tiger - Investigation Essential!"

It would seem that nearly two months later that someone is actually looking into the situation.

******************************************************************************

No roaring success: Binh Duong’s lax tiger pens

Due to a recent case in which a tiger in Dai Nam tourism park, Binh Duong Province, attacked and killed a zoo worker on September 13, SGGP reporters visited tiger breeding sites in the province to investigate conditions.

We went to the breeding site of Pacific Beer Co. in Noi Hoa Hamlet 1, Binh An Commune, Di An District, where 31 tigers and tigresses are kept.

The first thing that struck us was that the tigers are kept in unsafe breeding facilities, which stand next to crowded residential zones instead of in isolation.


A tiger breeding site erected next to private houses in Binh Duong Province (Photo:SGGP)

Local residents said that the news of a tiger in Dai Nam’s zoo attacking and killing a worker had made them anxious for the safety of their families, as a tiger had once before escaped its cage and ran into a local resident’s house.

The owner of the house that had once been “visited” by a tiger, Le Thanh Thieu of Noi Hoa 1, narrated that some three years ago, the animal, weighing between 50 and 60 kilos, jumped over the breeding site’s fence and landed into his yard. He and other members of the family ran for their lives and into the house.

Thieu said, “ We stood trembling behind the locked the door while the tiger kept wandering around the house until a security guard from the company rushed to my home and tried to lure him back to the cage.”

He added, “A few years ago, when the tigers were just brought here, the company didn’t bother about building the fence for their breeding site, but grew bushes of Roses of Sharon as a substitute. The fences were built only after the escape of the tiger. Indeed, the local authorities forced the company to do so.”

Although living in a house surrounded by very high fences, Nguyen Thi Chien, another local resident, always feels fearful when hearing the tigers roaring from their cages. She said, “During the rut, the tigers roar all day and all night, particularly between 4am and 5am, I wake up and can never get back to sleep again.”

Aside from living in fear, local people have also been affected by the environmental pollution due to the disgusting odor from the breeding site.

According to the Binh Duong Province Forest Protection Agency, three businesses are currently allowed to rear tigers, as part of pilot conservation projects in the province: they are Thai Binh Duong Beer Co. in Di An District, Thanh Canh Tourist Zone in Thuan An District and Dai Nam Tourism Area in Thu Dau Mot District.

The agency said that after the tiger’s attack on the zoo worker, they could do nothing, but report the case to higher authorities.

At present, there are no official regulations on wildlife breeding nor standards for assessment whether or not tiger breeding facilities are safe.

Owners of the three breeding sites said that they had several times submitted their pilot breeding projects to authorities, but “they were rejected because they fail to meet standards.”

The question is raised as to how non-existent standards have been used by authorities to determine the businesses’ projects.

The nonsensical problem has not yet been solved.

At present, although the businesses have been allowed keep the tigers under pilot projects for some two years now, no one can say whether or not the breeding facilities or conditions for the tigers meet minimum standards.

And local residents living near tiger breeding sites are still apprehensive of dangers due to the fact that some day in the future, the tigers may jump over substandard walls and roar in their homes.

By Chi Thinh – Translated by Phuong Lan